With the rise of spam calls and fraudsters, identifying unknown callers has become essential. Two solutions dominating this space in india are CNAP (Caller Name Presentation) and apps like Truecaller. While they seem similar on the surface, their working, reliability, and regulatory backing differ significantly.
1️⃣ What is CNAP?
CNAP stands for Caller Name Presentation. It is an official telecom network-based service regulated by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of india (TRAI). CNAP allows the caller’s registered name to be displayed on the recipient’s phone whenever someone calls them.
- Unlike apps, CNAP works natively on your mobile network — no app installation required.
- The data comes directly from telecom operators’ verified customer information, making it more reliable than crowdsourced data.
- It works for all types of phones, including basic feature phones.
Example: If a registered subscriber named “Rohit Kumar” calls you, CNAP will show “Rohit Kumar” on your screen — even if you don’t have his number saved.
2️⃣ How CNAP Works
CNAP works in real-time through telecom infrastructure:
Caller Registration: When a customer registers a number with their operator, their name is linked to the number.
Call Initiation: When the caller makes a call, the telecom operator sends a CNAP request to the recipient’s network.
Name Transmission: The network checks the caller ID and sends the verified name along with the call to the recipient.
Display: The recipient sees the caller’s name on their phone screen before answering.
💡 Key Feature: CNAP is verified and regulated, so it’s harder to spoof compared to third-party apps.
3️⃣ What is Truecaller?
Truecaller is a third-party app that identifies calls using a crowdsourced database of phone numbers and names. It also offers features like spam detection, call blocking, and contact management.
- Truecaller relies on user-generated and public data, meaning it may show incorrect names if the number is not registered properly or if users have saved it differently.
- It requires installation and permissions, and sometimes access to your contacts to improve accuracy.
Example: Truecaller may show “Bank XYZ customer Service” for a call even if the operator hasn’t officially verified it.
4️⃣ CNAP vs Truecaller: Key Differences
Feature
CNAP
Truecaller
Source of Data
Telecom operators (official, verified)
Crowdsourced from users & public sources
Regulation
Regulated by TRAI
Private company, unregulated
Accuracy
High — name linked to official number registration
Variable — depends on user database
App Required
No
Yes
Works On
All phones, including feature phones
Smartphones only
Spam Detection
Limited
Yes, with crowdsourced spam reports
Cost to User
Usually free
Free, premium version available with extra features
5️⃣ Advantages of CNAP
- Reliable Caller Name Display: Since it comes from telecom operators, the name is officially verified.
- Works on Any Phone: Even non-smartphones display caller names.
- Low Privacy Risk: No third-party app collects your contacts.
- Reduces Fraud: Harder for fraudsters to spoof compared to unverified apps.
6️⃣ Advantages of Truecaller
- Spam Alerts: Warns you about telemarketing and fraud numbers based on crowdsourced reports.
- Extra Features: Includes call blocking, contact search, call recording (on supported phones).
- Cross-Platform: Works globally and identifies numbers not registered with indian telecom operators.
7️⃣ Limitations of CNAP
- Limited Spam Detection: CNAP primarily shows the name but doesn’t identify spam calls.
- Dependent on Telecom Registration: Only works for numbers that are officially registered with operators.
8️⃣ Limitations of Truecaller
- Accuracy Can Vary: Wrong names may appear if crowdsourced data is incorrect.
- Privacy Concerns: App accesses your contacts and call history to maintain the database.
- Internet Required: Truecaller needs a working data connection for real-time name lookup.
9️⃣ How Users Can Benefit
- CNAP: Use it for official, verified caller names, especially on feature phones or for people avoiding apps.
- Truecaller: Best for spam detection and smartphone call management, especially when the caller is not registered with telecom operators.
- Combined Use: Many users use CNAP for basic name display and Truecaller for spam alerts on the same phone.
🔑 Key Takeaways
CNAP is operator-based, verified, and regulated. Truecaller is app-based and crowdsourced.
CNAP works on all phones; Truecaller requires a smartphone and internet.
CNAP provides accuracy and authenticity, Truecaller provides spam detection and extra features.
For maximum protection, users can use both: CNAP for verified names, Truecaller for spam alerts.
CNAP is essentially India’s official solution for caller ID verification, while Truecaller is a convenience tool with extra features but with variable accuracy and privacy considerations.
Disclaimer:
The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of any agency, organization, employer, or company. All information provided is for general informational purposes only. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, reliability, or suitability of the information contained herein. Readers are advised to verify facts and seek professional advice where necessary. Any reliance placed on such information is strictly at the reader’s own risk.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel