In india today, even talking about merit can get you threatened with the SC/ST Act. A law that was meant to protect the vulnerable is increasingly being brandished like a sword against anyone who dares to ask uncomfortable questions about the reservation. The irony?
Merely discussing meritocracy isn’t even an offence under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. Courts themselves have said it. But fear rules the streets and the internet—speak up, and someone will slap the “Atrocities Act” threat on you. When debate becomes criminalised, democracy becomes hollow.
1. The Death of Debate
Reservation is one of the most explosive issues in India—but instead of engaging in dialogue, critics are silenced with legal threats. Question the system? You’re suddenly branded “anti-Dalit” or “casteist.”
2. Merit Became a Dirty Word
How did a simple word like “merit” get twisted into caste discrimination? It’s not casteist to ask for fairness—it’s common sense. Yet in India’s political climate, merit is treated like a slur.
3. Weaponising a Protective Law
The SC/ST Act was created to shield the most vulnerable communities from humiliation, violence, and centuries of oppression. But today, it’s being wielded against anyone who dares to tweet about exams, jobs, or college admissions.
4. Courts Have Already Clarified
Recent bombay high court rulings (Dec 2024) make it crystal clear: criticising reservations alone is not an offence. Unless there’s targeted insult, humiliation, or hate speech aimed at SC/ST individuals, the Act doesn’t apply. But try explaining that to online mobs armed with hashtags.
5. social media = New “Public View”
The law says atrocities must happen “within public view.” In the wallet PLATFORM' target='_blank' title='digital-Latest Updates, Photos, Videos are a click away, CLICK NOW'>digital age, twitter timelines and instagram reels count as public squares. That’s why the Act often gets invoked online—but debating systems isn’t the same as abusing communities.
6. A Chilling Effect on Free Speech
The real danger isn’t just false cases—it’s self-censorship. people stop questioning. They stop debating. They stop thinking. Because in today’s india, one angry complaint can ruin your career, your reputation, your life.
7. Broken Balance = Broken Democracy
A law that once protected dignity is now being misused to protect fragility. When protection becomes privilege, and privilege becomes a weapon, the line between justice and injustice disappears.
⚡Final Blow: India cannot call itself a democracy if talking about merit is treated like a crime. Protecting the vulnerable should never mean gagging the truth.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel