A video shared by RadioGenoa on X has ignited a controversy regarding the methods used by an Islamic preacher to educate women and young girls. The footage, which has gone viral, shows the preacher using a stick to guide the participants, drawing comparisons to how a farmer might handle livestock.
The video, lasting approximately 34 seconds, features a series of frames where a man dressed in white traditional attire is seen sitting on a chair, holding a stick. He appears to be instructing several young girls, who are dressed in various colored hijabs and traditional clothing, on how to step over a brick placed on the floor. The setting seems to be inside a mosque or a similar religious institution, with a tiled floor and minimal furnishings.
Subtitles in the video include phrases like "Utba mila ghensa maula ali ko" and "Aanke kholi to dekha kahle nabi ko," which suggest a religious or cultural context, possibly related to Islamic teachings or practices. The preacher's use of the stick to physically guide the girls' movements has been interpreted by some as a form of discipline, leading to accusations of authoritarianism.
The thread following the post includes diverse perspectives. Some users question the broader implications of such practices within islam, with one asking, "1.8 billion on the planet with mental illness?" Others suggest that the video might be taken out of context, urging a deeper understanding of the cultural nuances involved. Defenders of islam argue that the religion itself promotes education and compassion, and that such practices might be localized rather than representative of Islamic doctrine as a whole.
Critics, however, point to historical and contemporary instances where similar methods have been used, raising concerns about gender dynamics and the treatment of women and children in certain Islamic communities. The discussion also touches on the role of education within islam, with references to the high value placed on learning and the historical emphasis on scholarly pursuits.
The video, lasting approximately 34 seconds, features a series of frames where a man dressed in white traditional attire is seen sitting on a chair, holding a stick. He appears to be instructing several young girls, who are dressed in various colored hijabs and traditional clothing, on how to step over a brick placed on the floor. The setting seems to be inside a mosque or a similar religious institution, with a tiled floor and minimal furnishings.
Subtitles in the video include phrases like "Utba mila ghensa maula ali ko" and "Aanke kholi to dekha kahle nabi ko," which suggest a religious or cultural context, possibly related to Islamic teachings or practices. The preacher's use of the stick to physically guide the girls' movements has been interpreted by some as a form of discipline, leading to accusations of authoritarianism.
The thread following the post includes diverse perspectives. Some users question the broader implications of such practices within islam, with one asking, "1.8 billion on the planet with mental illness?" Others suggest that the video might be taken out of context, urging a deeper understanding of the cultural nuances involved. Defenders of islam argue that the religion itself promotes education and compassion, and that such practices might be localized rather than representative of Islamic doctrine as a whole.
Critics, however, point to historical and contemporary instances where similar methods have been used, raising concerns about gender dynamics and the treatment of women and children in certain Islamic communities. The discussion also touches on the role of education within islam, with references to the high value placed on learning and the historical emphasis on scholarly pursuits.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel