🌀A Holy Dip or a Dirty Deception?
The yamuna River, long reduced to a slow-moving gutter of industrial waste and untreated sewage, suddenly found itself in the spotlight this Chhath Puja — not because it was cleaned, but because it was filtered. As lakhs of Bihari devotees braved the toxic froth and stench for their sacred rituals, a pristine, man-made pond reportedly appeared for one man: Prime minister narendra Modi.
The optics were divine; the irony, blasphemous. The same river that gasps for breath every year was granted a brief illusion of purity — but only for the cameras.
🌊 For Biharis: Filthy Sewage Water of the Yamuna
For decades, the yamuna has been the very definition of neglect. Delhi’s sewage plants discharge millions of litres of untreated waste daily. Devotees performing Chhath Puja in this river wade through grey foam — a frothy cocktail of industrial chemicals, human excreta, and effluents.
Every year, visuals of women standing waist-deep in toxic sludge make the rounds, stirring outrage for a day or two before disappearing into the next news cycle. This year, however, those same visuals collided with a new one — a carefully staged scene of the prime minister dipping in what appeared to be crystal-clear water.
💧 For narendra Modi: A Man-Made Filtered Pond
According to allegations by the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), the BJP-led delhi administration created a special, filtered pond near Vasudev Ghat, using clean water — possibly piped in from the ganga via sonia vihar — to facilitate the Prime Minister’s ceremonial Chhath Puja dip.
The water was reportedly filtered, sanitized, and possibly chlorinated — a level of cleanliness that’s unthinkable for the average devotee. The setup looked divine on camera: serene water, saffron shawl, folded hands, and the perfect lighting for a narrative of devotion and leadership.
But if true, it wasn’t a dip in the Yamuna — it was a dip in a manufactured illusion.
🧱 AAP’s Allegation: PR Over Purity
AAP leaders wasted no time calling out what they dubbed “ritual theatre for reels.” They accused the bjp of creating a photo-op, not a clean river — a symbol of how political power sanitizes reality for optics while the public drowns in the consequences.
delhi minister Saurabh Bharadwaj alleged that the clean pond was a “Modi-only zone” — filtered for one man while crores of devotees were left to risk infections and rashes from toxic water. AAP’s charge was simple but damning: “If you can clean a pond for Modi, why not clean the river for everyone?”
🧿 BJP’s Defence: “Political Filth, Not River Filth”
The bjp swiftly dismissed the allegations as political propaganda. Leaders claimed that the arrangements were made for everyone’s safety and convenience — not just for the Prime Minister. They pointed to the installation of sewage treatment plants (STPs) and recent “improvements” in yamuna water quality as proof of their commitment to cleaning the river.
But even official reports by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) tell a different story: Yamuna’s faecal coliform levels remain dangerously high, and most of its stretches in delhi are still unfit for bathing or ritual use.
💀 Holy Water or Toxic Soup? The Environmental Reality
Let’s be brutally honest — the yamuna isn’t a river anymore. It’s a corpse on life support. Every day, it receives over 3,000 million litres of untreated sewage, and industrial pollutants have turned its bed into a toxic sludge pit.
While a single day’s filtration can clean a pond for cameras, cleaning the yamuna requires years of political will, infrastructure reform, and accountability — not press releases.
Yet the tragedy is that for millions of Bihari migrants and Delhi’s working class, this poisoned water remains sacred. They have no choice but to find faith in filth — while the powerful manufacture purity for their portfolios.
📸 The politics of Optics
Modi’s ritual dip was more than a photo-op — it was a masterclass in political theatre. The spotless pond symbolized not just devotion but control: control over narrative, imagery, and emotion.
For a leader who thrives on symbolism, this was yet another moment of myth-making. But when myth meets the muck of the Yamuna, the contrast becomes impossible to ignore. One india gets clean water for spectacle. The other gets slogans about cleanliness.
⚖️ The Final Irony: Clean Image, Dirty River
In a nation where crores of rupees are spent on river rejuvenation projects that barely move the needle, the Yamuna’s condition is an annual reminder of hypocrisy. It reflects how cleanliness in india is often cosmetic — an act, not an ethic.
So, when the prime minister of the world’s largest democracy dips into a filtered pond while citizens choke on sewage foam a few meters away, it’s not just environmental failure — it’s moral collapse.
🔥 Mic-Drop Ending
The yamuna didn’t need a filtered pond.
It needed a leader brave enough to face the real river — the one that reeks, bubbles, and tells the truth.
Because faith doesn’t need clean water.
But governance damn well does.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel