A software engineer earning ₹50 LPA in Bangalore pays nearly ₹30 lakh in taxes in just five years — enough to fund government schemes, infrastructure, and welfare for millions. But if that same engineer is suddenly laid off, india gives them nothing. No unemployment benefits. No social security cushion. No income support.
Just: “Good luck. Try again.”
In a country that proudly calls itself socialist, the very people who fund the system are the only ones left outside the safety net.
1️⃣ The Numbers Don’t Lie: Taxpayers Pour Money In — The System Pours Nothing Back
A ₹50 LPA earner contributes around ₹6 lakh per year in direct taxes. Across five years, that’s nearly ₹30 lakh—the price of a house in many indian cities. Yet when layoffs hit, india offers no monthly support, no insurance-backed income, no emergency allowance. The people keeping the economy afloat are treated as disposable.
2️⃣ Developed Countries Protect Their Earners — india Leaves Them Hanging
In the US, UK, Canada, Germany, Australia, Japan, taxpayers who lose their jobs get:
unemployment cheques
housing assistance
healthcare continuity
social security
job retraining support
structured re-employment programs
In India?
A taxpayer who loses their job gets zero rupees and zero support, despite years of paying the government lakhs.
3️⃣ india Claims to Be Socialist — But Only for Those Who Don’t Pay Taxes
india gives:
free electricity
free bus travel
free water
cash transfers
scholarships
pension-style schemes
free ration for years
But only to those not contributing significantly to the tax pool. The biggest contributors — middle-class taxpayers — get absolutely nothing. Welfare goes down the income ladder; responsibility goes up.
4️⃣ The Harsh Truth: india Taxpayers Fund the Freebies They Don’t Benefit From
The painful irony?
The person who paid ₹30 lakh in taxes helped fund:
Ladli Bahen
Free electricity
Free bus rides
Free sanitation benefits
Flood relief
Food security programs
…and receives none of it back.
India’s system isn’t welfare — it’s reverse welfare, where the productive subsidize everyone except themselves.
5️⃣ Losing Your job in india Means Immediate Financial Panic
Your EMIs don’t stop.
Your rent doesn’t stop.
Your medical bills don’t stop.
But your income does — instantly.
And unlike other nations, where governments step in until you regain stability, india leaves taxpayers to survive purely on savings.
6️⃣ The Middle Class Pays for Everything — And Qualifies for Nothing
When it comes to government benefits, the middle class is too:
rich to receive help
poor to afford private solutions
small in voting power to matter politically
They are permanently stuck in the “you pay for others, nobody pays for you” category.
7️⃣ This Is Not Welfare. This Is Punishing Productivity.
A system where contributors are ignored and non-contributors are rewarded is not welfare. It’s a perverse incentive design.
When the government gives everything for free to non-taxpayers and nothing to taxpayers, it sends a message:
“Don’t work too hard… it doesn’t pay.”
That kills ambition. That kills innovation. That kills long-term national growth.
8️⃣ india Desperately Needs a Real Social Security Net
A modern economy must protect all workers — not only those who fall below the poverty line. india needs:
unemployment insurance
income-protection schemes
retraining support
emergency allowances
temporary financial assistance
Because the taxpayers who keep the machine running also deserve a seatbelt when the road gets rough.
9️⃣ A Nation Cannot Thrive on Exploiting Its Most Productive Citizens
India’s middle class is shrinking emotionally, financially, and psychologically. They feel squeezed from all sides — rising taxes, no support, no safety, no recognition.
If india wants to grow, it must stop treating taxpayers as ATMs and start treating them as partners in nation-building.
🔥 Final Word
Those who fund the system get nothing.
Those who don’t fund it get everything.
That is not equality.
That is not fairness.
That is certainly not socialism.
It is a system designed upside-down — and india cannot afford to keep it that way.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel