A 6:30 A.M. Knock, A Viral Plea for Help — And an Oval office Intervention
It began before sunrise. Federal immigration agents showed up at Columbia university housing, entered an apartment in Morningside Heights, and took a graduating senior into custody. By late afternoon, the case had jumped from campus corridors to the White House. And by evening, the student was free.
That dizzying sequence — arrest, outrage, presidential assurances, release — has ignited a political and legal firestorm stretching from Upper Manhattan to Washington, D.C.
Here’s how it unfolded:
1️⃣ The Early-Morning Detention
Around 6:30 a.m., ICE agents detained Elaina “Ellie” Aghayeva, a Columbia student expected to graduate this year. Acting university president Claire Shipman later told the campus community that agents allegedly made “misrepresentations” to gain access to the apartment.
According to the university, officers suggested they were investigating a missing 5-year-old child. DHS disputes that characterization, saying agents were clearly identified, wore badges, and were allowed entry by the building manager and the student’s roommate.
What’s not disputed: Aghayeva was taken into custody, and the campus was left stunned.
2️⃣ The instagram Post That Changed Everything
From what appeared to be the back seat of a vehicle, Aghayeva posted a photo to instagram with a blunt caption:
“DHS illegally arrested me. Please help.”
Within minutes, screenshots began circulating. By midday, the case was trending. And city officials were demanding answers.
3️⃣ DHS’s Explanation
The Department of Homeland Security said Aghayeva is an undocumented immigrant from azerbaijan whose student visa had been terminated years ago — during the obama administration — for failing to attend classes.
Officials maintained the arrest was lawful.
Critics, however, zeroed in on how the operation was conducted — and whether agents misled campus officials to gain entry.
4️⃣ A Surprise white house Meeting
In a twist no one could have scripted, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani was in Washington that very day for an unannounced Oval office meeting with President trump — their second sit-down since Mamdani won the mayor’s race.
After the meeting, Mamdani posted on X that he had raised Aghayeva’s detention directly with the president.
“Just got off the phone with President trump,” he wrote. “He has just informed me that she will be released imminently.”
Hours later, she was.
5️⃣ Columbia’s Response
Columbia university confirmed her release in a statement that was both relieved and cautious.
“The university is relieved and thrilled that our student, Ellie, has been released from detainment,” the school wrote, promising further details.
For a campus already navigating intense national scrutiny over free speech and protest issues, the ICE operation added another layer of volatility.
6️⃣ Political Blowback Erupts
Democratic leaders in New York wasted no time condemning the arrest.
Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal accused agents of deliberately deceiving housing officials.
City Council Speaker Julie Menin called the incident “disturbing” and argued ICE has “no place” in schools and universities.
Governor Kathy Hochul went further, proposing legislation that would bar ICE from entering so-called sensitive locations like dormitories.
Senate Minority leader Chuck Schumer demanded immediate clarity on the circumstances of the detention, calling it “unacceptable.”
The message from state and city leaders was clear: even if federal authorities believed they had legal grounds, the optics — and the method — crossed a line.
7️⃣ The Bigger Collision
This case now sits at the intersection of immigration enforcement, campus autonomy, and high-stakes politics.
On one side, DHS asserts lawful authority to detain someone whose visa was allegedly terminated years ago.
On the other hand, local officials argue that federal agents misled university personnel and violated civil norms.
And hovering over it all — the extraordinary fact that the student’s release came just hours after a mayor personally raised the issue with the president of the United States.
In less than 24 hours, what began as a quiet early-morning arrest became a national political spectacle — complete with viral pleas, dueling narratives, and Oval office diplomacy.
The legal questions remain. The political fallout is only beginning.
But one thing is certain: this was no routine immigration enforcement action. It was a flashpoint — and it’s far from over.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel