The Damage From Inside
Every major political movement faces opposition. That’s normal. What’s less discussed—and far more dangerous—is the damage caused by overzealous defenders who mistake volume for virtue and loyalty for logic. In the case of the Bharatiya Janata Party, a subset of unapologetic supporters has become a paradoxical liability—undermining persuasion, alienating moderates, and shrinking the party’s intellectual oxygen.
🧠 The Psychology Behind the Problem
1. Identity Fusion: When politics Becomes the Self
Identity fusion occurs when political allegiance fuses with personal self-worth. Criticism of the party is experienced as a personal attack. Debate becomes impossible because disagreement feels existential.
2. Reason Gives Way to Reflex
Once fused, responses default to taunts, whataboutery, and sarcasm. Evidence is optional; deflection is mandatory. The goal shifts from understanding to “winning” the exchange.
3. Moral Disengagement Sets In
Every action—good, bad, or indefensible—is reframed as a “masterstroke.” Accountability is suspended. Ethics become conditional on who’s asking.
4. In-Group Narcissism Takes Over
Belonging to the camp becomes proof of moral superiority. Dissenters aren’t wrong; they’re malicious. Outsiders aren’t critics; they’re enemies.
🧨 Why This Backfires Politically
5. It Repels the Movable Middle
Centrists, soft supporters, and undecided voters don’t leave because of ideology—they disengage because the discourse feels crude, dishonest, and exhausting.
6. Labels Replace Answers
When every question is met with “anti-national” or “anti-Hindu,” curiosity dies. people don’t convert; they tune out.
7. Confidence Morphs Into Contempt
Power paired with mockery looks less like strength and more like insecurity. Arrogance without competence is universally repellent.
⚖️ The Strategic Cost
8. The Party’s Emotional Space Shrinks
Instead of expanding appeal, hyper-defensiveness narrows it. Nuance becomes risky. Questions become betrayals. The movement looks brittle, not bold.
9. From Organisation to Identity Group
Over time, the party risks appearing less like a confident political organisation and more like a cult-like identity group—where loyalty is prized over thinking.
🧠 The Uncomfortable Truth
Opposition harms a party from the outside.
Unthinking defenders damage it from within.
Movements grow by persuading the undecided, not by humiliating them.
🧨 Closing Punch
If support cannot tolerate scrutiny, it isn’t strength—it’s fragility.
If loyalty requires silencing questions, it’s not confidence—it’s fear.
The bjp doesn’t need louder defenders.
It needs calmer arguments, better answers, and the courage to let logic—not mockery—do the talking.
Because in politics, arrogance narrows the road—and persuasion is the only thing that widens it.
click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel