The ongoing trade war between the US and china has reshaped global supply chains, and india has been positioned as a potential beneficiary. But is this really a golden opportunity, or are there hidden challenges—and even controversies—that indians should be aware of?

1. The Promise: Why india Could Benefit
* Manufacturing Shift – Companies like Apple, Samsung, and tesla are diversifying away from china, and india is a top alternative.
* government Push – Schemes like PLI (Production-Linked Incentive) offer subsidies to attract factories.
* Geopolitical Advantage – The US sees india as a strategic counterbalance to china, leading to more investments and tech partnerships.

But… is india really replacing China?

2. The Controversy: Why India’s Gains Are Limited
A. "Made in India" Still Relies on China
India imports $100+ billion worth of Chinese goods annually, including critical components for electronics, pharma, and EVs.

Controversy: Even if final assembly happens in india, much of the supply chain still depends on China.

B. Bureaucracy & Slow Reforms
Land acquisition, labor laws, and infrastructure delays frustrate investors.

Controversy: Vietnam, Thailand, and mexico are moving faster, stealing investments meant for India.

C. job Growth vs. Automation
Factories coming to india are highly automated—meaning fewer jobs than expected.

Controversy: Is "Make in India" creating enough employment, or just benefiting big corporations?

D. US Double Standards?
The US pushes india to open its markets but still protects its own industries (e.g., agriculture, tech).

Controversy: Will india get fair access to US markets, or remain a junior partner?

3. The Big Question: Who Really Wins?
Big Businesses (like Reliance, Tata, Foxconn) gain from subsidies and exports.

Consumers may face higher prices if local manufacturing isn’t cost-efficient.

Workers may not see massive job growth if automation dominates.

Controversial Take: Is india becoming just an "assembly hub" for global firms rather than a true manufacturing powerhouse like china was?

4. What Should indians Watch For?
🔹 Will PLI schemes actually boost self-reliance, or just enrich a few corporates?
🔹 Can india reduce its dependence on Chinese imports?
🔹 Will the US grant india better trade terms, or keep protectionist policies?

Final Verdict: Opportunity, But With Risks
India is gaining from the US-China trade war—but not as much as it could. Without faster reforms, better infrastructure, and smarter policies, the benefits may stay limited to a few sectors.

The real controversy?
Is India’s leadership overhyping the gains while ignoring the structural problems holding the country back?

What do you think? Is india on the path to becoming the next global factory, or will it miss this historic chance?

Why This Matters to Ordinary Indians?
Jobs? Will manufacturing growth translate into real employment?

Prices? Will "Made in India" goods be cheaper or costlier?

Tech & Innovation? Or will india remain a low-value assembly line?

This isn’t just about economics—it’s about whether india can truly leverage this moment to become a self-reliant industrial power.
For more interesting updates wa click and follow Indiaherald WhatsApp channel

Find out more:

Sindujaa D N

16/04/2025 10:45 PM